Reverts the default value of Environment.glow_hdr_threshold from 0.0
back to 1.0 to restore the expected glow appearance in existing projects.
The default was inadvertently changed from 1.0 to 0.0 in PR #110077,
which caused glow effects to render dramatically different across all
rendering methods (Forward+, Mobile, and GL Compatibility). This broke
backward compatibility with existing projects like the Kenney 3D
Platformer starter kit.
Changed files:
- scene/resources/environment.h
- servers/rendering/storage/environment_storage.h
- drivers/gles3/effects/glow.h
- drivers/gles3/rasterizer_scene_gles3.cpp
- doc/classes/Environment.xml
Setting the value back to 1.0 aligns with documented recommendations
and restores visual consistency.
Fixes#112469
Mobile devices are typically bandwidth bound which means we need to do as few texture samples as possible.
They typically use TBDR GPUs which means that all rendering takes place on special optimized tiles. As a side effect, reading back memory from tile to VRAM is really slow, especially on Mali devices.
This commit uses a technique where you do a small blur while downsampling, and then another small blur while upsampling to get really high quality glow. While this doesn't reduce the renderpass count very much, it does reduce the texture read bandwidth by almost 10 times. Overall glow was more texture-read bound than memory write, bound, so this was a huge win.
A side effect of this new technique is that we can gather the glow as we upsample instead of gathering the glow in the final tonemap pass. Doing so allows us to significantly reduce the cost of the tonemap pass as well.
This commit changes adjustments to behave as follows for all rendering configurations:
- Apply brightness to linear-encoded values, preventing contrast, saturation, and hue from being affected.
- Apply contrast to perceptually uniform (nonlinear sRGB-encoded) values, matching existing behavior when HDR 2D is disabled and producing optimal visual quality.
- Apply saturation with even color channel weights. This causes brightness of certain colors to change, but matches existing behavior when HDR 2D is disabled.
Adjustments are applied after glow and tonemapping to match existing behavior.
Additionally, change the minimum `tonemap_white` parameter to `1.0`; users can increase `tonemap_exposure` for a similar effect to decreasing `tonemap_white` below `1.0`.
Co-authored-by: Hei <40064911+Lielay9@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Hugo Locurcio <hugo.locurcio@hugo.pro>
Silc Lizard (Tokage) Renew
Thaddeus Crews
kobewi
Per Lindstrand
Chaosus
Claude
Pāvels Nadtočajevs
Rémi Verschelde
clayjohn
Michael Alexsander
jon1solution
Aaron Franke
Ryan
Norbert Zentai
Allen Pestaluky
Skyth
Yufeng Ying
Lukas Tenbrink
scgm0
Kaleb Reid
lawnjelly